Willie didn't dress during my two days at camp last week, but he participated in some running back drills early in practice and looked fine. And now it looks like he'll play. But that doesn't guarantee anything beyond the Redskins game, and Jim Wexell has a nice write-up on Gary Russell. I love Verron, but if Russell and Carey Davis make the cut -- along with FWP, Najeh and Danny Kreider -- I'd be cool with that.
Plus, it would just give more credence to my DON'T DRAFT RUNNING BACKS ON THE FIRST DAY mantra that everybody already pretty much agrees with. (It's kinda like arguing that ice water is a much better way to quench your thirst on a hot day than, say, Jägermeister. Yeah, no shit.) In addition to having two, young, relatively healthy runners, Pittsburgh will also get some special teams help. I realize Haynes was a valuable special teamer, and a better third-down back -- both as a blocker and a pass catcher -- but he's forever battling injuries and that's kind of a problem.
But back to Timmons. If I remember correctly, I wanted Adam Carriker, Patrick Willis, or Levi Brown should any of them be available at 1.15. All three were gone, and frankly, there wasn't a lot left that particularly interested me. Here's the second half of the 2007 first rounders, and nobody jumps out at me as worthy of the 15th overall pick.
16 Justin HarrellI would've been fine if the Steelers took Beason, Spencer, Staley or Grubbs, but preferably only after a trade down. And if the o-line generally, and Max Starks specifically have another craptastic effort Saturday, I might be on the "Pittsburgh shoulda taken Staley/Grubbs with the 15th overall pick ... and maybe even traded up to make sure they got one of them" bandwagon.
17 Jarvis Moss
18 Leon Hall
19 Michael Griffin
20 Aaron Ross
21 Reggie Nelson
22 Brady Quinn
23 Dwayne Bowe
24 Brandon Meriweather
25 Jon Beason
26 Anthony Spencer
27 Robert Meachem
28 Joe Staley
29 Ben Grubbs
30 Craig Davis
31 Greg Olsen
32 Anthony Gonzalez
But Randy Steele makes an important point: fans aren't so much calling a Timmons a bust (well, the smart fans, anyway), they're just frustrated because no one knows what he can do. I'm willing to wait, because, well, Timmons didn't have much of a role on the 2007 team to begin with. It would be nice if he could play a little special teams, and, you know, learn a little something about the defense by some other means than mental reps, but there's really no reason to rush the guy. (Unless you think fans' impatience is a legit reason). Instead of getting all huffy about Larry T., we should all worry about the more immediate problems: which running backs will make the final 53, and how long until the Steelers call Todd Fordham to replace Max Starks at right tackle (hello, 2003!)
|